Tuesday 28 July 2015

TV Review: Titanic: Blood & Steel

As I hail from Northern Ireland, the RMS Titanic is part of my cultural history and one of early moments of history I remember learning about in school.  The Titanic was built in Harland & Wolff Shipyard which is in Belfast and the two cranes David and Goliath are part of the Belfast skyline.

Harland & Wolff are well known for building great ships.  Unfortunately though the Titanic sank.  2012 marked 100 years since the ship sank and there many commemorations for this event and some TV shows were made about it.  One of these shows was “Titanic: Blood and Steel” which I recently watched.

Titanic: Blood and Steel is a series of 12 episodes and it was a slow burner to start off with but then it got interesting. It is a show not just about the building of the Titanic – there are plenty of other themes in it:

  • Religion) especially the difference between Protestant and Catholic (only in Northern Ireland!!)
  • Upper class v lower class
  • Home Rule
  • Trade Unions
  • Politics
  • Irish Republican Army
  • Poverty
  • Romance / Love
  • Death

The show had some big names in it:

  • Derek Jacobi as Lord Pirrie – a leading Irish shipbuilder and businessman.  He was Chairman of Harland & Wolff between 1895 and 1924.  He was also Lord Mayor of Belfast between 1896 and 1898).
  • Neve Campbell as Joanna Yeagar – a New York Journalist
  • Chris Noth as J.P Morgan - an American financier and founder of the J.P Morgan bank.  Another one of his ventures was International Mercantile Marine (IMM). One of the subsidiaries of IMM was White Star Line who were the owners of RMS Titanic.   Morgan died in 1913, a year after the RMS Titanic sank.

The series follows the lives of the shipbuilders, the financiers, the aristocratic families of Belfast and those who worked in office posts at Harland & Wolff.  Most of the characters are portrayals of real people like Thomas Andrews, J. Bruce Ismay and Lord Pirrie etc.  However, the central character Dr Mark Muir is a fictional character (portrayed by Keven Zegers – a Zac Efron lookalike). Dr Muir is an engineer and metallurgist (a person who specialises in metal).  He convinces J.P Morgan to hire him to work on the Titanic and succeeds.

Dr Muir claims to be a Londoner and speaks all posh. However, he is actually a native of Belfast and was born Marcus Malone but changed his name to Mark Muir in order to hide his identity and progress in his world of academia.  He tries to hide his heritage from his current employers Harland & Wolff because he is a Catholic and his employers are Protestant elite that rule Belfast and dislike Catholics.

When they find out that the real identity of Dr Muir they sack him as he is Catholic and no Catholics should ever be in management as apparently they are untrustworthy.  However after the sister ship The Olympic gets bashed in a crash, J.P Morgan insists Muir is brought back on the payroll as he is the best at his job.  The board do not like this but as Morgan is financing the Titanic then what he says goes and Dr Muir is rehired.

Dr Muir’s background isn’t the only thing to annoy the Board. He also insinuates that the steel used by the shipbuilding company were using was cheap steel, which apparently was a concern for the real shipbuilders building the RMS Titanic.  However, it has been documented that the steel plates used were of good quality of that period of time.  The reason why the Hull broke on impact with the iceberg was not because of structural weakness but because the strains imposed upon it were simply greater than any ocean liner was designed to bear.  And the hull only broke during the last few minutes of the ship sinking.

Tensions rise between the lower class workers and the rich elite which was due to sectarian discrimination as Harland and Wolff hired predominantly Protestant workers and only a few Catholics.  Though in the programme it shows that there were mostly equal numbers but in reality that is not true.  The Protestants did not want to work alongside Catholics so the Catholics rioted against this.
In the series the riots are apparently because of safety and wage issues, but Harland & Wolff’s wages were considered fair. It is the sectarian tensions which were the driving force of the rioting.  These riots were a setback for the construction of the Titanic, as were the workers wish to form a Trade Union., the woman suffragettes movement in the UK and the battle between pro Home Rule (a belief that all Ireland should remain an independent republic and pro Unionist (the political union between Ireland & Great Britain).

When RMS Titanic was built Ireland was all one country and only separated into Northern Ireland Southern Ireland 10 years after the Titanic sunk in 1922.

There are a many other historical errors in the show mainly regarding the Olympic (the sister ship) which was launched in October 1910 while the RMS Titanic was launched on May 2011.

There was a love story in the series as well which was between Dr Muir and Sofia Silvestri (an Italian immigrant and illustrator for Harland & Wolff).  Their relationship was up and down and in the end she had decided to go to New York to make a career in design and he wanted to stay in Belfast.

The series ended with the maiden voyage of the RMS Titanic which in reality was from Southampton to New York but in the show it sailed from Belfast.

Many of the shows main character board the RMS Titanic all ready for a new life in America.  As they all boarded I wondered which ones would have survived and which ones would perish.  I felt like shouting at the TV, no don’t get on the ship, it sinks!!


It was an interesting series, quite addictive and one day I ended up watching five episodes in one day! 

No comments:

Post a Comment